In many marine surface sediments, the reduction of manganese (Mn) and iron (Fe) oxides is obscured by sulfate reduction, which is regarded as the predominant anaerobic microbial respiration process. However, many dissimilatory sulfate and sulfur reducing microorganisms are known to utilize alternative electron acceptors such as metal oxides. In this study, we tested whether sulfate and sulfur reducing bacteria are linked to metal oxide reduction based on biogeochemical modeling of porewater concentration profiles of Mn2+ and Fe2+ in Bothnian Bay (BB) and Skagerrak (SK) sediments. Steady-state modeling of Fe2+ and Mn2+ porewater profiles revealed zones of net Fe (0–9 cm BB; ∼10 and 20 cm SK) and Mn (0–5 cm BB; 2–8 cm SK) species transformations. 16S rRNA pyrosequencing analysis of the in-situ community showed that Desulfobacteraceae, Desulfuromonadaceae and Desulfobulbaceae were present in the zone of Fe-reduction of both sediments. Rhodobacteraceae were also detected at high relative abundance in both sediments. BB sediments appeared to harbor a greater diversity of potential Fe-reducers compared to SK. Additionally, when the upper 10 cm of sediment from the SK was incubated with lepidocrocite and acetate, Desulfuromonas was the dominant bacteria. Real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) results showed decreasing dsrA gene copy numbers with depth coincided with decreased Fe-reduction activity. Our results support the idea that sulfur and sulfate reducing bacteria contribute to Fe-reduction in the upper centimeters of both sediments.